Candy Floss: 18 Months on Loan and Still Holding Its Shape

One of the questions we hear most from new builders is whether PLA is good enough for a telescope. It's the easiest filament to print, but it has a reputation for slowly sagging under load, which is called creep. A little drift in collimation isn't the worry, since collimating is routine. The worry is parts slumping or warping out of shape until the scope doesn't work any more.
Candy Floss gave us a good chance to find out. It's the Skyward 150 Compact we built in the Build the Skyward 150 video, with every pink and mint part printed in Silk PLA. It has spent the last 18 months in the Blue Door Astronomy Library, going home with borrowers on four-week loans.

What We Looked At
We didn't take measurements when we built it, so this isn't a lab result. Instead we compared the build video with how the scope looks today, at the spots where creep would show first.
The feet. The whole scope sits on the mint domes at the bottom of each leg. They're scuffed from being set down outside, but still round, with no flattening.
The tube rings and star wheel. Still square, and the tube doesn't sag.


What It Means for Your Build
If you're printing a Skyward in PLA and it will live indoors and come out at night, it should hold up fine. Where you need to be careful is heat. PLA starts to soften at around 55 to 60 °C, and a hot car or a sunny window can get there, so don't leave it in either. If your scope will see that kind of abuse, print the structural parts in PETG, ABS or ASA.
For the materials side of the story, including why Silk PLA has a weak reputation, see Does PLA Creep? on the Tundra 3D blog.
Want to see Candy Floss for yourself? It's available to borrow from the library.




Comments